Comments on: MultiGrain Forum: eBooks and Memory http://www.against-the-grain.com/2011/07/multigrain-forum-ebooks-and-memory/ Linking librarians, publishers and vendors Sat, 18 May 2013 19:36:22 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.4.1 By: Tony Horava http://www.against-the-grain.com/2011/07/multigrain-forum-ebooks-and-memory/comment-page-1/#comment-34066 Tony Horava Wed, 03 Aug 2011 16:48:22 +0000 http://www.against-the-grain.com/?p=6452#comment-34066 Good comments. I agree that this conversation is a subset of a much larger dialogue - on the breadth of material we read via screens for many purposes, whether for leisure, or work, or study, or pinpointing a nugget of needed information in different contexts (as you have noted Brandon). Yes, as we move further and further into the digital world, the old habits are likely to die off and new habits/expectations will supplant them. It will be an important cultural challenge to assess the impact of this on reading habits, navigational styles, technological interaction and the morphing of memory into a much more collective dimension. This will be harder for many digital immigrants who grew up with the traditional expectations and habits re reading practices and behaviours...but some will make the transition better than others. Good comments. I agree that this conversation is a subset of a much larger dialogue – on the breadth of material we read via screens for many purposes, whether for leisure, or work, or study, or pinpointing a nugget of needed information in different contexts (as you have noted Brandon). Yes, as we move further and further into the digital world, the old habits are likely to die off and new habits/expectations will supplant them. It will be an important cultural challenge to assess the impact of this on reading habits, navigational styles, technological interaction and the morphing of memory into a much more collective dimension. This will be harder for many digital immigrants who grew up with the traditional expectations and habits re reading practices and behaviours…but some will make the transition better than others.

]]> By: Brandon Nordin http://www.against-the-grain.com/2011/07/multigrain-forum-ebooks-and-memory/comment-page-1/#comment-34031 Brandon Nordin Tue, 02 Aug 2011 23:05:34 +0000 http://www.against-the-grain.com/?p=6452#comment-34031 This discussion needs to take place against the context of the entire volume of screen read material - not just books. Let's face it - that's the dominant mode of text to person interface these days. And just as reading reports, newspapers and love letters on screen seems more and more natural every year, so it will be with books, as habituated behaviour, improving technology and adapting publishing methods align. It will of course lead to new ways of retention and use - just as being able to easily clip a photograph to an email, or add a tag a caption to that photograph, then pass it onto the world via Facebook has changed the distribution pattern and understood use of that medium - as well as its role in personal and group memory. For me, as a prolific and fairly wide grazing reader - and recent iPad convert, the new experience has already meant: - it is far more difficult to flip back and forth (lets say between endnotes and the relevant chapter, or between sequenced instructions (as in a how to book) in an ebook than a physical work) There seems an obvious technology solution here - but in general, geo-locating within an e-work requires a specific action, like a bookmark, vs visual memory and instinct. - conversely, because I am seamlessly online, I am far more likely to look up a word in a dictionary, explore the location of a battlefield, and even purchase works referenced to, as part of my e-reading experience. So I am still able to seek references and supporting information - but a different subset, in a different manner. Like most socio-technologic transitions, some things once thought essential to the old experience will be lost...and but new modalities, habits and expectations will arise that soon become embedded 'must have' components to the experience. This discussion needs to take place against the context of the entire volume of screen read material – not just books. Let’s face it – that’s the dominant mode of text to person interface these days. And just as reading reports, newspapers and love letters on screen seems more and more natural every year, so it will be with books, as habituated behaviour, improving technology and adapting publishing methods align.

It will of course lead to new ways of retention and use – just as being able to easily clip a photograph to an email, or add a tag a caption to that photograph, then pass it onto the world via Facebook has changed the distribution pattern and understood use of that medium – as well as its role in personal and group memory.

For me, as a prolific and fairly wide grazing reader – and recent iPad convert, the new experience has already meant:
- it is far more difficult to flip back and forth (lets say between endnotes and the relevant chapter, or between sequenced instructions (as in a how to book) in an ebook than a physical work) There seems an obvious technology solution here – but in general, geo-locating within an e-work requires a specific action, like a bookmark, vs visual memory and instinct.
- conversely, because I am seamlessly online, I am far more likely to look up a word in a dictionary, explore the location of a battlefield, and even purchase works referenced to, as part of my e-reading experience. So I am still able to seek references and supporting information – but a different subset, in a different manner.

Like most socio-technologic transitions, some things once thought essential to the old experience will be lost…and but new modalities, habits and expectations will arise that soon become embedded ‘must have’ components to the experience.

]]>